Jamal Lyles, LB, Southfield (mi) - MSU VERBAL

[Marklar]

Neither, they already have one top 100 guy along with a solid QB and can be considered the leader for Jaleel Johnson and maybe Monty Madaris. Also, they have a good shot at Mahone. Not to mention they have several solid commits already. Are they going to have a top 20 class, probably not, but they aren't doing bad at all, IMO.

They will be lucky to be a top 30 class with the way things are going.

[toleb12]

They will be lucky to be a top 30 class with the way things are going.

Damn, I was hoping MSU would get that recruiting trophy this year too.

[knuckles311]

is this sarcasm or a question?

If a question, not really.

I'm curious to hear your reasoning for why you think MSU is recruiting so poorly. Lucky to have a top 30 class? What makes you qualified to make that analysis? Do you even know anything about MSU recruiting, who we are after, or who we are in good shape to get, outside of what you hear on UM message boards?

[Cheech]

I f they get Johnson and can close O'brien that will be a very formidable defense in a couple years with Pittman, Johnson, OBrien, Gholston and the kid they got last year Lawrence?

[toleb12]

I'm curious to hear your reasoning for why you think MSU is recruiting so poorly. Lucky to have a top 30 class? What makes you qualified to make that analysis? Do you even know anything about MSU recruiting, who we are after, or who we are in good shape to get, outside of what you hear on UM message boards?

Is any one really qualified in recruiting?

[phillyfan]

Is any one really qualified in recruiting?

Motorcityjoe

[tommyz]

nice pick up

[Marklar]

I'm curious to hear your reasoning for why you think MSU is recruiting so poorly. Lucky to have a top 30 class? What makes you qualified to make that analysis? Do you even know anything about MSU recruiting, who we are after, or who we are in good shape to get, outside of what you hear on UM message boards?

Personal opinions.

[knuckles311]

Is any one really qualified in recruiting?

I would say that a person who follows MSU recruiting is a tad more qualified to make that assessment, as opposed to one who doesn't. Thats why I posed the question asking to what extent he actually follows it.

[Marklar]

I would say that a person who follows MSU recruiting is a tad more qualified to make that assessment, as opposed to one who doesn't. Thats why I posed the question asking to what extent he actually follows it.

I am sort of trolling.

But so you know, I do follow MSU a little bit. I am just saying that while MSU and their fans will probably like the class because thats how they are, nationally, it won't be looked at as favorably.

[knuckles311]

I am sort of trolling.

But so you know, I do follow MSU a little bit. I am just saying that while MSU and their fans will probably like the class because thats how they are, nationally, it won't be looked at as favorably.

Judging what happens with Ward, Johnson, Mahone, Madaris, O'Brien, Burbridge, Norfleet, etc, it could end up being top 25 when all is said and done (which would be pretty good considering we are taking under 20). I guess it kinda just solidifies your point...yes, I would be very happy with that, lol.