fair trade?

[GF-22a]

let me know what you think please....

team A gets : reggie wayne (74 points) pettigrew (43 points) #85 (41 points) b.marshall (62 points)

team B gets: harvin (50 points) williwams (29 points) cutler (99 points) keller (72 points) burlerson (23 points in like 1 1/2 games)

[the King]

I'd rather be team A unless I was really hard up for a QB

[LionSB06]

Team A has the better end of the deal. Wane and Marshall are the best 2 players in this trade and they are getting both of them.

[GF-22a]

I'd rather be team A unless I was really hard up for a QB

team B had the 33 ranked QB in the leauge... so yeah they were hard up for a QB

[GF-22a]

Team A has the better end of the deal. Wane and Marshall are the best 2 players in this trade and they are getting both of them.

point wise (and i know that's not the end all be all but then again don't you want the players with the most points?) team B is getting the #1 and #3 players.

[FastFreddie]

point wise (and i know that's not the end all be all but then again don't you want the players with the most points?) team B is getting the #1 and #3 players.

You can't compare a QBs points to a WRs. Cutler might have 99 points, but is probably the #30th QB, while Wayne @ 74 points might be the #3 WR.

You could probably PU a QB off of waivers, that has close to Cutlers 99 points.

[GF-22a]

You can't compare a QBs points to a WRs. Cutler might have 99 points, but is probably the #30th QB, while Wayne @ 74 points might be the #3 WR.

You could probably PU a QB off of waivers, that has close to Cutlers 99 points.

cutler is the 19th QB (and he's had his bye...right or was he just injured) and wayne is like 15th as WR. keller is #2 in TE. what does it matter what slot you put a player in as long as he gets you the most points?

[GF-22a]

i mean wayne has 74 points and keller has 72.... it's not like wayne counted for more points because he's a WR and keller is a TE.

[LionSB06]

i mean wayne has 74 points and keller has 72.... it's not like wayne counted for more points because he's a WR and keller is a TE.

Keller has been a stud for sure and it would be nice to land him BUT I just think your giving up a ton in Marshall and Wayne to land Keller and Cutler . The rest is garbage in that trade.

[GF-22a]

Keller has been a stud for sure and it would be nice to land him BUT I just think your giving up a ton in Marshall and Wayne to land Keller and Orton. The rest is garbage in that trade.

is it unfair IYO?

keep in mind... marshall did get almost 30 points in one game. so you take that game out and he's done nothing to speak of

[LionSB06]

is it unfair IYO?

Not unfair just to much of a price to pay for a TE and a decent QB that will be hurt a bunch more going forward. Whats the QB situation for the guy getting Cutler?