Okay, so here is a quick, unscientific look at how well the recruiting sites predict future success. There are tons of different ways to look at this, and my method is woefully inadequate, but hopefully we’ll get a general idea. The records at Scout and Rivals go back to 2002. I'll try to take a look at ESPN soon, but their damn 100-point system makes comparisons difficult.

So, basically I just looked at the first-round draft picks in the NFL going back to 2005 and saw how each site rated them. Here are the results:

2005 Draft – There were only seven players from this draft in the two sites’ databases.

Rivals – 4 four-stars, 1 three-star, 2 two-stars
Scout – 1 four star, 4 three stars, two unrated players

The two sites disagreed about every one of these players:

Alex Smith (02) – Rivals 2*, Scout NR
Adam Jones (02) Rivals 2*, Scout NR
Troy Williamson (02) – Rivals 4*, Scout 3*
Mike Williams (02) – Rivals 4*, Scout 3*
Shawne Merriman (02) – Rivals 4*, Scout 3*
Fabian Washington (02) - Rivals 4*, Scout 3*
Aaron Rodgers (03) – Rivals 3*, Scout 4*

2006 Draft – Eight of the players taken in the first round of the 2006 Draft were 2001 recruits, and thus, there was no official ranking for them at any of the sites. Of the 24 remaining players drafted that year:

Rivals – 5 five-stars, 13 four-stars, 4 three-stars, 2 two-stars
Scout – 6 five-stars, 8 four-stars, 3 three-stars, 2 two-stars, 5 unrated players

The two sites agreed on 12 players. The disagreements were as follows:

Reggie Bush (03) – Rivals 5*, Scout 4*
Donte Whitner (03) – Rivals 4*, Scout 5*
Broderick Bunkley (02) – Rivals 4*, Scout NR
Antonio Cromartie (03) – Rivals 4*, Scout 5*
Laurence Maroney (03) – Rivals 4*, Scout 2*
Manny Lawson (02) – Rivals 2*, Scout NR
Davin Joseph (02) – Rivals 4*, Scout 3*
Jonathan Joseph – (04) Rivals 3*, Scout 4*
Santonio Holmes (02) – Rivals 3*, Scout 4*
John McCargo (02) – Rivals 2*, Scout NR
De’Angelo Williams (02) – Rivals 4*, Scout NR
Nick Mangold (02) – Rivals 4*, Scout NR
...

Sportsinferno.com member Aaugusti shares his summary of the Detroit Lions Town Hall for Season Ticket Holders.
...

Scott Shafer Out

Michigan defensive coordinator Scott Shafer resigned today, which appears to have been a ...

The Big Ten, the ACC and the Big 12 all have something in common, and it may not be something that hits you right away. ...

I just dont get it. Since 1934 the Detroit Lions have played football on Thanksgiving Day. No matter the Lions record it is something that Lions and football fans have looked forward to for 74 years...That ...

The past week saw a pair of big name athletes make their debuts on the Detroit sports scene. Daunte Culpepper made the start ...

On the same Sunday that the Detroit Lions fell to 0-7 at Ford Field, Head Coach Rod Marinelli's 22nd career loss, Mike Singletary of the San Fransisco 49ers ...

No clue.

Still not over this weekend and how it went down.

Losing is one thing. I can deal with that. Not showing up is another.

Embarrassing yourself , crapping your pants, and looking clueless is tough to handle.

It had been two years since I'd seen something ...

There has been plenty of speculation over the past several weeks regarding the names that ultimately will appear on the list of candidates to replace former NFLPA Executive Director ...

31-84... That is the Lions record (as of 09/22/2008) during the Matt Millen era.

An era defined accurately defined as the worst 8 consecutive years in NFL history.

Where lies the blame ? Was this a coincidence of injuries ? Perhaps a plane crash or catastrophic team illness ?

No.. the blame here rests with talent.. or lack there of. Lack of talent on the field.. lack of talent coaching the players on the field.. lack of talent managing the team.. lack of talent owning ...

Everyone in the Metro Detroit area should just meet at Hart Plaza and have a huge party.

I'm going to have ...

You are looking at a photo of what might be the dumbest man alive. No really... I mean, I understand in the blogosphere there are a lot of stupid people.

There are the wack jobs that think George W. Bush was smart enough in 8 months to plan the attack on the World Trade Centers and rig both sky scrapers up with explosives plus ...

Now.. right off the back, I realize that everything that has happen to the Lions isn't the media's fault.. I'm not saying that.

But in roughly 10 months, the Free Press along with the Detroit News drove Kwame Kilpatrick out of office... granted... he had committed felony crimes.

But aren't William Clay Ford & Matt Millen felons against the fans of Lions ...

After watching this once proud man dominate the field for 16 seasons I have had enough of him. The man once stood for being ...